1. Billions of people all over the world have been shaking their heads in shock, wondering how the USA elected a man like Donald Trump to be their President. Throughout his election campaign his vile intentions, motives and views had been clear for anyone to see and hear. He is now not so much a President as an ongoing serious political crisis, at the head of the most powerful country on earth.
Trump’s Personal Trustworthiness - or Lack of It
2. Trump epitomises (among other ills) patriarchy
in an extreme form. In fact, Trump’s deep mysogyny and sexism were well-established many years before the USA's 2016 election campaign even began. His business involvements with Casinos, model agencies and the Miss universe contest had thrown up a number of fundamental questions about his personality and behaviour. Stories about the trafficking of young models and drugs at parties hosted by Trump have been swilling around in the US press and media for years.
3. During his election campaign he was caught on tape bragging about his sexual assaults on women. At the time of writing
(late 2017) he has so far been accused of sexual misconduct by 16 women. A group of these women have asked the US Congress to investigate him. Since he took up office the whole world has seen how he is unable to stop himself from bragging about multiple things - anything. Asked a serious question about a serious matter he will often leave the question and start bragging and inflating his own ego. Everything is about self-aggrandising - he is primarily about selling himself and his 'brand', driven solely by his self-image.
4. As his campaign progressed it was obvious that his flagrant lying, misogyny, sexism, racism, xenophobia, fascism (more on this below) and other multiple defects are all packaged inside an emotionally immature, impetuous, narcissistic, ignorant, egomaniac who is simply a Con Artist. Fundamentally, that is what he is : A trash-talking real estate Con Artist, with a lust for money and power, among other things. In his first year in office he has shown that he is capable of crossing just about every red line there is. It is a horrifying problem that the whole world is watching unfold - in the leader of the most militarily and financially powerful nation on earth, helped by his enablers, collaborators and supporters.
The USA’s Business-Political Culture - Trump is an Unsurprising Result
5. His life inside the USA’s toxic business culture (including in celebrity TV) has meant that he has never needed to have any coherent or respectable political philosophy, which could be debated, challenged and investigated. His fascism (more on this below) - like all fascism – emerges from his own ignorance and thrives on the complacency of others. Trump began his ‘career’ with the privileges of his father’s fortune plus some shark-like instincts which he has used (despite some major ‘mistakes’) to con his way to a bigger fortune in the real-estate world. Underneath all this, the descriptors ‘sociopath’ and psychopath’ are the key to defining the internals of the Trump problem. He could not care less about the massive harms he does to anyone else, he is oblivious to them. All that matters in Trump world is himself.
6. With enough experience of life, you might have come across people with some of these traits before and you can spot problem personalities like Trump at a distance. Anyone who studies his history will see that the ‘Trump Problem’ has been running through his whole adult life (i.e. five decades). From birth he has lived as a privileged and increasingly rich person inside the USA’s hyper-capitalist
and toxic business-political culture. In his business life there have been bankruptcies, defaults, people have been ripped off, and there have been many, many lies. Through all of this his vile and narcissistic personality traits have been encouraged to develop unchecked.
7. Trump is not alone, either in the US or globally. Within the US he is one of many thousands of rich and powerful people with similar mindsets and instincts, moving around in the same toxic political-business culture – the advanced form of today’s neoliberal capitalism
. He is
now surrounded in his cabinet and his administration by thousands of like-minded millionaires, billionaires, business people, press and media moguls, celebrities and Republican party supporters, all sharing most (or all) of his venal right-wing mentality. Too many in the current US Democratic party have been the same or very similar. Trump has many enablers and collaborators and they are all complicit in what he is doing. Like Russia (and plenty of other countries) the USA is no longer a democracy but an Oligarchy, run by and for the tiny minority that is the ultra-rich. Their big money funds the political parties, the politicians, the mainstream press and media to deliver the political culture and the policies which will expand their own wealth and power. The counter side of this is that the mass majority of citizens are having all the destructive policies of ‘Austerity’ shoved down their throats.
8. When the minority (only 27%) of the USA's eligible electorate voted for Trump (whatever else they were thinking) they were choosing between two evils offered to them by the US’s two-party Oligarchy. They clearly chose a con artist. Both the candidates stood for the interests of the rich, of Wall Street and of corporate power. All US Presidents over the past several decades (at least) have shared this loyalty to the rich, so Trump is just the latest – albeit very dangerous - progression of this pattern. Most of his policy preferences are the same as or similar to other recent US Presidents, candidates, politicians or elite political groups. He is really an outcome or consequence of the bigger problems with the US’s political-business culture and system.
Systemic Problems Opened the Door To Trump
9. It helps to remember that Trump was elected into the most powerful position in the world by only 27% of the USA’s eligible electorate. Many of the electorate chose not to vote and many were prevented from voting (as always
happens in the USA’s nightmarishly dysfunctional version of ‘democracy’). Why those 27% could not distinguish this man as a con artist is a question to ponder. The answer seems to be that people like him and the values he personifies have been normalised over many decades within the US and its political-business culture. So, nobody should have been surprised when his campaign promises to look after the interests of ‘the working man’ were immediately dropped after he took office. Since then Trump has been doing the opposite - that's what Con Artists do. The reality is that Trump and his Republican Party set to work destroying public and welfare services, implementing lavish tax giveaways for the rich and inflicting tax increases on the poor. They are also trying to reshape the American Constitution to suit themselves and their super-rich and corporate friends, rigging the system to benefit themselves even more in the longer term.
10. However bad Trump has been so far (this was written in December 2017), sadly the worst of him is probably yet to come. He and his collaborators and enablers are implementing more and more policies that poison and divide the USA and threaten security across the world. People are right to be very anxious about him but Trump is an unsurprising consequence of three even bigger and long-term systemic US problems :
(a) Firstly the awful state of the money-centred and lies-driven toxic US business-political culture (this has suited him very well throughout his rise in business and politics) - it has given Trump many enablers, collaborators and supporters;
(b) Secondly the defects in the US Constitution and electoral system (which allowed a person like Trump to gain presidential power).
(c) Thirdly, the inability of the US Constitution and Laws to, without delay, suspend or dismiss a bad leader (and his many collaborators) and make them accountable for things which should be unconstitutional or illegal.
11. Even if Trump was to disappear tomorrow, these big problems with the US Constitution and political culture would still exist and need to be solved. He alone is not ‘the big problem’. The big problem is that of
‘State Capture’. The US has long ago been captured, taken over by the extreme right-wing economic elite, the rich, big business and corporations, interested only in enriching themselves at the expense of ordinary citizens and weaker countries. Trump is an outcome / consequence of these bigger systemic problems in the USA. However old and dysfunctional this system is, it could be changed. The election system could be changed. The funding of elections could be changed. The qualifications and qualities of candidates could be assured by a ‘quality system’. The Presidential role and responsibilities could be changed. Policy changes made by Trump could one day be reversed. More socially just policies could eventually be taken forward. Much could be changed but we will not let hope overtake expectations.
Trump in the White House – A World of Wrongdoings
12. We looked above at Trump’s problematic personality before he took office. Turning to the problems he is now causing in office, we can here only scratch the surface of this ongoing political crisis. Even before the day he took office he had already established himself as (and partly turned the USA into) a laughing-stock across the whole world – but a very dangerous one, who now has his finger on the USA’s military and other resources and on its nuclear button.
13. Since Trump entered office in January 2017 the shock and disbelief has not subsided but grown with daily examples of his gross personality defects, irrational decisions, impetuous announcements often via Tweets, and the implications of these for the citizens of the USA and the world. Below we will just highlight a few actual examples of what he has done so far. In his first year in office there have been so many alarming Trump words or deeds – we are all spoiled for choice - but we have just picked a few.
(a) Trump's Nepotism
14. Trump is inimical to democracy. His nepotism was clear from the start. His wife, children and other family members attend important meetings, including with leaders of other states. They are presented by Trump as if they are elected representatives of the USA – of course none of them are any such thing. They turn up in important meetings of international bodies as the official representatives of the US. Neither the US Constitution nor the Laws of the country or its political-legal institutions seem to prevent this. Through his family and associates he also appears to have effortlessly preserved his own vast business interests in close parallel with his role as President – apparently untroubled by the law or the constitution.
(b) Divide and Rule – By a Poisoning, Polarising Politician
15. His poisonous personality has continued fomenting division and anxiety within the USA. It is a country now
more divided and destabilised than it has been since its Civil War in the 1860s. Everything about him is deeply divisive. The fact that only 27% of the eligible electorate voted for him gives hope - if this base of public support declines. If it does, then the possibility that he will be impeached by his own Republican party will increase. But don’t hold your breath. The Republicans are finding that having Trump drawing all the attention to his ‘shop window’ is giving them great cover, diverting public attention away from other Trump problems, keeping some of what they have been doing out of sight, in the shadows. The Republican party has always depended on ‘divide and rule’ as a core of their strategy and Trump is a perfect fit with them.
(c) Trump’s Travel Ban
16. One of his promises during the 2016 election campaign was his islamophobic travel ban on people from Muslim-majority countries. This has caused much outrage around the world but Trump listens only to his own bigotry and to others who are equally bigoted. After a few months of legal blocks the US Supreme Court voted to allow the wholesale implementation of the measure in relation to six countries, pending the outcome of various legal challenges. That was an important legal victory for Trump. It may be months or years before the Supreme Court delivers a final verdict.
(d) Trump - The Fascist President
17. In August 2017 Trump praised racist and hate-filled, torch-bearing neo-Nazi Ku Klux Klan (KKK) white supremacists (many of them armed) at a rally in Charlottesville, Virginia. He suggested that these neo-Nazis KKK white
supremacists and those demonstrating peacefully against them were both to blame for the deadly violence that broke out in Charlottesville. Trump claimed that the neo-Nazis KKK were merely expressing peaceful disagreement with the planned removal of a statue of the confederate slavery-supporting Robert E. Lee. The Fascist and fact-averse Trump was utterly wrong.
18. The demonstrators standing against the neo-Nazis KKK engaged in no violence whatsoever. The whole event was filmed by TV crews and many social media users. The only violence was committed by the neo-Nazi KKK white supremacists. One of them drove a car at speed into the peaceful demonstrators, injuring several and killing Heather Heyer, a 32-year-old legal assistant with a law firm in Virginia, who was a champion of civil rights. The demonstration, of which she was part, against the neo-Nazi KKK white supremacists was entirely peaceful and legal. Shortly afterwards a 20-year old man was arrested and charged with Heather Heyer’s murder.
19. The torch-bearing was hugely significant in the US because it is a direct ‘take’ from the awful rallies, lynchings and burnings carried out by the fascist and racist KKK through the twentieth century. The current leader of the KKK lead the neo-Nazi fascists in Charlottesville. For any US politician (nevermind a President) to support neo-Nazi KKK white supremacy sent big shock waves throughout the US and around the world.
20. Numerous world leaders (even some not very worthy ones) quickly criticized Trump,
condemned him for his views and disassociated themselves and their countries from him. A commonly expressed point was that : “There is no equivalence between those who propound fascist views and those who oppose them”. Trump’s profound ignorance and bigotry underpins all his racist, fascist views and he can obviously never see that he is wrong (about anything), much less ever admit an error. The whole world understands this about him and it has been confirmed by his own actions and words many times – this is a serious character weakness in Trump.
21. Among many criticisms of Trump from other leaders were :
• "The 'leader of the free world' loses moral authority when he cannot call fascism by its name"
• "The president of the United States has just turned his face to the world to defend Nazis, fascists and racists. For shame."
• ”Trump has shown he is unable to detach himself from the extreme right and racial supremacists"
• "What happened in Charlottesville was the Ku Klux Klan and its supporters, white supremacists, arrived in Charlottesville in order to cause trouble. Surely every president of every country in the world should be able to condemn that."
22. Even leading figures in Trump's Republican party reacted angrily to his comments, with House Speaker Paul Ryan saying: "White supremacy is repulsive. There can be no moral ambiguity.” Senator Elizabeth Warren (Democrat) expressed outrage : "The president of the United States just defended neo-Nazis and blamed those who condemn their racism and hate," She declared on Twitter : "This is sick." Since then Trump has stuck to his disgraceful views, forever faithful to his own ego.
(e) ‘Taking A Knee’ Highlights Trump’s Fascism
23. We applaud the many professional sports people and others in the USA who, following Charlottesville (see above) chose not to stand for the US national anthem but to go down on one knee – to ‘take a knee’.
24. Colin Kaepernick, a quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers, first kneeled during the playing of ‘The Star-Spangled Banner’ national anthem in August 2016 to protest against the multiple killings of African Americans by US police officers. Some other players then followed this example. In September 2017, at a rally in Alabama Trump ranted about football players who took the knee during the national anthem, calling on the football club owners (“friends of mine”) to fire any “son of a bitch” who dared to protest.
25. Later, on Twitter, Trump retracted an invitation that had been given to NBA champions the Golden State Warriors to visit the White House after the team’s star player, Stephen Curry, expressed reservations. This action by Trump ensured that the ‘Take a Knee’ protest went viral. Dozens of football stars and other athletes took the knee over that weekend, as did musicians Stevie Wonder, Pharrell Williams and John Legend. Now, because of his Alabama rally rant (and his accompanying Tweets) the target was clearly Trump.
26. In this and other ways Trump is making himself perhaps the best inspiration for protest ever seen in the USA. Many famous black athletes and entertainers have protested in the past. In 1964 Baseball hero Jackie Robinson abandoned the racist Barry Goldwater’s Republican party in 1964, because it had given him “a better understanding of how it must have felt to be a Jew in Hitler’s Germany”. The great boxer Muhammad Ali risked
jail and the end of his career by refusing the Vietnam war draft in 1967. Athletics stars Tommie Smith and John Carlos raised their gloved fists in a salute for human rights (often called the Black Power salute) while standing on the winners podium at the 1968 Mexico City Olympics. They had just won the Gold and Bronze Medals in the 200 metres final. The Australian winner of the Silver Medal Peter Norman was told in advance by Smith and Carlos what they planned to do on the podium and, to his everlasting credit, he said “I’ll stand with you”. In 1974 the musician Stevie Wonder taunted the then President Richard Nixon in ‘You Haven’t Done Nothin’, which topped the US charts the week that Nixon was forced to resign over his Watergate scandal . After Hurricane Katrina, the singer Kanye West said on live TV : “George Bush [then President] doesn’t care about black people”. On the issue of ‘taking a knee’, as on so many other issues Trump behaves like a vindictive and impetuous bully with the attention span of a small child.
27. In Trump’s world he imagines that everyone should, exactly like him, see the American flag and the national anthem as the highest, most sacred symbols, not so much of America’s stature but of his own importance, his own stature. He assumes that he is integral with the symbols of state and that everyone should defer to him and accept his word on all things. His support for the neo-Nazi white supremacists at Charlottesville (see above) and his
reaction to ‘Taking a Knee’ are about as clear a sign of fascism as you can ever get. Think of Hitler in Germany, Mussolini in Italy and Franco in Spain - these were the three most infamous fascist leaders in history (but not the only ones), responsible for carnage in their own countries and elsewhere on a horrendous scale. They insisted that they were the State, the State was embodied by them, they were the absolute rulers, everyone else was subservient to them. They insisted that their sick version of ultra 'patriotism' must be followed by everyone - the symbols, insignias, flags and anthems of the state were entirely tied up with their own personal image and power which must be defended and displayed above all else. They employed highly stage-managed public rallys, placing themselves above everyone else, at the centre of every event. Trump is copying them. The inside of Trump’s head is a home for this fascism. He wants every public appearance, every one of his stage-managed rally and every state occasion to reflect his self-importance. There is no doubt that this is a fascist mindset. His many enablers, collaborators and supporters are all complicit in this Fascism. So, we applaud the ‘Taking of the Knee’ and all other refusals to submit to Trump’s fascist desires.
(f) Global Instabilities Created by Trump the ‘Moron’
28. Trump has exacerbated tensions across the world and introduced dangerous new instability with threats in many directions (North Korea, Venezuela, Iran, etc). His obvious and profound ignorance, his multiple misconceptions, his impulsiveness are ensuring that the sense of alarm and fear is rising with the passing of each month. Many commentators and observers across a wide political spectrum in the US have acknowledged that he is the worst President the USA has ever had.
29. Many people who are part of his ‘natural’ support in the Republican Party have already spoken out against him. His current Secretary of State Rex Tillerson (the former President of the Exxon Oil Corporation) is reported to have called Trump a ‘Moron’.
(g) Trump Threatening North Korea – Nuclear Nightmares Again
30. In August 2017 Trump threatened to unleash “fire and fury like the world has never seen” on North Korea if it continued to expand its nuclear weapons programme. Shortly afterwards the Republican Chairman of the US Senate Foreign Relations Committee accused trump of setting the US “on a path to World War III”. Subsequently, this Committee, for the first time in over 40 years, started to examine the US President’s
authority to launch a nuclear attack. Senator Chris Murphy (Democrat, Connecticut) explained the reason for this : “We are concerned that the President is so unstable, is so volatile, has a decision-making process that is so quixotic, that he might order a nuclear weapons strike that is so out of step with US national security interests”. That is a good assessment of Trump and they are right to be wary of his role in relation to nuclear weapons. He is so ignorant of all international diplomatic or political conventions that he has - again and again - openly promised to commit war crimes as a matter of policy.
31. In the meantime, Trump’s personality is taking the world back to the extreme tensions of the ‘Cold War’ era. When tension is high, the possibility of an error or a misreading of events increases. With Trump in office it is important to remember how previous periods of international nuclear tension involving the USA arose. Some of us recall that in 1961 the USA tried to invade Cuba at the Bay of Pigs and failed. The next year the USA and Soviet Union confronted each other over US ballistic weapon deployments in Italy and Turkey (aimed at the Soviet Union). At the same time Cuba and the Soviets agreed they would deter the US from any future invasion attempts on Cuba by jointly setting up a ballistic missile launch facility in Cuba. Then, in September-October 1962, US spy planes discovered and photographed nine weapon sites in Cuba and also Soviet missiles on board a Soviet ship approaching Cuba. After a couple of weeks of stalemate, threats, and secret negotiations (and with the whole world holding its breath and in a state of intense stress) the US and Russia both backed away from this imminent all-out nuclear conflict. As part of the agreements reached by them the USA and Russian weapons in Cuba, Italy and Turkey were then removed.
32. This ‘Cuban Missile Crisis’ was the closest the world has yet come to nuclear war. The
Trump v North Korea dispute, though different in its character, may be heading towards a similar critical moment. However, since Kim Jong–un seems to be at least as quixotic and impulsive as Trump, its possible that critical mistakes and misjudgements might be made, leading to disaster. The risks in the Trump v Iran scenario are also high. Trump has said repeatedly that he will scrap the world’s means of dealing with Iran’s nuclear activities, so its impossible to say what will happen next in this fraxious relationship. Certainly, the quixotic, impulsive and vindictive Trump should be kept well away from any military decisions, if we all want to stay safe.
(h) Did Russia Help Trump Get Elected ?
33. In January 2017 the US intelligence services concluded that Russia had tried to sway the Presidential election in Trump's favour. Former US intelligence chiefs say Trump's denial that any Russian meddling helped him gain power at the 2016 election is now putting the US at risk. Trump caused uproar by saying he believed Russia’s President Vladimir Putin who told him there had been no Russian interference. The two leaders had briefly discussed the allegations at an Asia-Pacific summit. Trump also disparaged key figures in the US intelligence community who concluded in January that Russian meddling had taken place.
34. Former national intelligence chief James Clapper said he was alarmed by the president's comments that : "Every time he [Putin] sees me he says ‘I didn't do that’, and I really believe that when he tells me that, he means it," Mr Trump told reporters. "I think he is very insulted by it, which is not a good thing for our country." For a US President to be so at odds with the US Intelligence services would appear to be a dangerous place for a President to be. Congress has set up a Special Counsel to investigate this matter and these findings could be very interesting. There are already signs that this is not going all Trump’s way. Let’s hope so.
(i) Trump’s In Need of ‘Day Care’ – He’s Debasing the Nation
35. Bob Corker, Republican Senator for Tennessee and on the verge of retirement (so possibly with nothing to lose) tweeted : “It's a shame the White House has become an adult day care center. Someone obviously missed their shift this morning.” Corker followed this with an Interview with the New York times and included a few more damning quotes : "I don't know why the president tweets out things that are not true. You know he does it, everyone knows he does it, but he does."…"A lot of people think that there is some kind of 'good cop, bad cop' act underway, but that's just not true."…"I know for a fact that every single day at the White House, it's a situation of trying to contain him."
36. Following this, in a series of television interviews, Corker again accused the president of lying. Nobody in the White House has so far accused him of 'defamation of character' and sued him. They would obviously have no basis for that because Corker is simply telling the truth, speaking 'Truth to Power'. The influential Senator Corker unleashed a blistering attack on Trump, calling him "utterly untruthful". In a series of television interviews, Corker accused the president of lying, adding that he debased the US and weakened its global standing. Corker added : "He is purposely breaking down relationships we have around the world that had been useful to our nation."…"I think the debasement of our nation is what he'll be remembered most for" he said. The Senator added that the president has "great difficulty with truth".
(j) Trump's Drone Killings
37. Over the past decade or so the USA’s Presidents have authorised the illegal killings (murders) of hundreds of people around the world using Drones
and ‘automatic aircraft’. About one third of the people killed have been innocent children. Many more have been innocent adults, guilty of no crimes other than being somewhere near one of the USA’s ‘targets’. These murders are said to be ‘signed off‘ by the President in routine weekly meetings and carried out by Drone Operators work their shifts, sitting safely inside bases in the US or on board US warships.
(k) Parties, Models & Drugs : Trump's Mysogyny & Sexism
38. In the course of his election campaign Trump’s business activities and involvements with a model agency and the Miss Universe contest threw up a number of fundamental questions about his personality and behaviour. The stories of the trafficking of young models and drugs at
parties Trump hosted in the 1990s have surfaced in the US press and media. During his campaign he was also caught on tape bragging about his sexual assaults on women and at the time of writing (late 2017) he has so far been accused of sexual misconduct by 16 women. A small group of these women have asked the US Congress to investigate him. Trump epitomises (among many other ills) patriarchy and mysogyny in an extreme form. He is not so much a President as an ongoing serious political crisis, in charge of the most powerful country on earth.
(l) Trump’s Administration is Alone in its Extreme Denial of Climate Science
39. By November 2017 all of the original 195 parties to the UN Paris Agreement on Climate Change
had ratified the agreement and were fully signed up to support it – that is all except one – the USA. Trump had previously announced he would pull the USA out of the agreement and he did this in June 2017. The Paris Agreement is the world’s agreement and plan (although it is far too weak) to reduce the man-made greenhouse gas emissions which are warming our planet, raising sea levels and leading us into humanity’s biggest ever problem (more here
40. Since then Trump's White House has also tried to downplay a major climate change report, which was compiled in 2017 by 13 of its own US federal agencies. This report contradicts assertions from Trump and several senior members of his administration. Trump had previously made the ridiculous claim that the concept of global warming was invented by the Chinese in order to make American manufacturing less competitive. Running to nearly 500 pages, the 2017 report confirms the view of climate scientists globally that the current period is "now the warmest in the history of modern civilisation"…It is "extremely likely that human activities, especially emissions of greenhouse gases, are the dominant cause" adding that "there is no convincing alternative explanation". Trump and his collaborators are in complete denial about all of this.
41. He has already made it easier for US industry to pollute, he has appointed to key government positions people who represent the interests of the US fossil-fuel corporations, he has set about tearing up regulations which protect the environment, he is reinvigorating a declining coal industry and giving the fossil fuel corporations all kinds of subsidies. He is doing all this at a time when scientists globally, the UN and the other 194 countries in the Paris agreement
are seeking ways to leave fossil fuels (oil, gas and coal) as far as possible where they are – in the ground. Trump’s collaborators are not just dismissive of their own scientists but also, like Trump, they are irrational and fundamentally fact-averse. Like Trump they are psychopathic in their disregard of the fact that global warming is being caused by burning fossil fuels. They are simply closing their eyes and ears to the irreversible catastrophe all this entails for global humanity.
42. Fortunately, there are hundreds of Towns, Cities, States, Universities, Businesses, and other Organisations in the USA who ARE pushing ahead despite Trump. They are a growing and already powerful group and they are all working together to make sure that their parts of the USA do fulfil their Climate Change commitments under the Paris Agreement
. They went to the November 2017 meeting of all the other 194 countries who are committed to tackling change. This large group from the USA registered their support for the global commitment to tackle climate change - in no uncertain terms. They were welcomed by all the other states and parties present and they had quite an impact. Trump's administration sent only a small delegation of fossil fuel corporations to promote their own narrow business interests and they had only a trifling effect in the meeting.
(m) Trump Claims Jerusalem as Capital for Israel
43. In December 2017 Trump announced that the US would be moving its Israeli embassy from Tel-Aviv to Jerusalem and declared that Jerusalem was now the new ‘capital’ of Israel. Trump’s arbitrary and reckless
announcement is contrary to all existing UN and other international attempts to manage and sort out the Israel-Palestine situation. Trump has simply thrown fuel on the smouldering flames of this extremely dangerous situation in the most dangerous region of the world.
44. Firstly, Trump’s intervention is a dangerous violation of international law. It can have no legal impact on the situation and is as good as void. Secondly, neither Trump nor the US have any agreed international rights or role in deciding on other nation’s capitals. Thirdly, Trump’s endorsement of Israel’s attempt at ‘grabbing’ all of Jerusalem as its capital contradicts long-standing US policy. Fourthly, US policy has long been that the city’s status must be decided in negotiations with the Palestinians, who want East Jerusalem as the capital of their future state under the internationally promoted ‘two-state solution’. Lastly, not only does the US not have any right arbitrarily to intervene in a wholly one-sided way in favour of Israel in this situation, Trump’s intervention will achieve nothing.
45. Trump's need for attention has recklessly fanned the flames and could plunge this most dangerous region into violent reactions and result in many unnecessary and avoidable deaths. Shortly after Trump's announcement
57 predominantly Muslim nations called on the world to recognise "the State of Palestine and East Jerusalem as its occupied capital". It also said that Trump's illegal move had signalled the USA's withdrawal from its role in the Middle East peace process and that the UN should take over this role. Clearly, the US would be unacceptable as a 'mediator' because it is biased in favour of Israel. Trump's reckless action is seen widely across the world as an attack on the rights of the Palestinian people. Later in December 2017 the UN voted to rescind Trump's (and anyone else's) claims to make Jerusalem the Capital of Israel.
Who Is Responsible for This Mess ?
46. However terrible Trump becomes we must keep things in perspective and never forget to ask the right questions, for example : Is the bad leader causing bad governance or vice-versa ? Which comes first, the
chicken or the egg ? In this case the bad leader (along with all his supporters and enablers who are complicit in his wrongdoings) has risen to power through the electoral system while the constitution and laws have not stopped him, so the ultimate responsibility lies with the US system. All of the big concerns and risks now being faced are a consequence of the US’s system deficiencies being exploited by a bad politician with the help of his enablers and collaborators. Remember : Only 27% of the eligible electorate voted for him, so it would be a mistake to blame the whole population for this dire situation. It is a system problem which has allowed Trump into power and unless the system is fixed another similar, or worse, problem could (probably will) happen again in future.
Can Things in the USA Ever Be Better ?
47. Trump has brought the USA’s own deepest structural nightmares and darkest systemic demons up into the daylight. These are self-created by the USA and it must now face and overcome these as best it can. If it fails to move onto a path of real justice and democracy, then the consequences for the US and the whole world could be very dark indeed.
48. In a more perfect USA, the country would have a constitution, electoral system and laws that would spot and exclude people like Trump (and his many enablers) very early, and prevent them from ever having any role in public life whatsoever. There cannot be any doubt that there are plenty of very good people across the USA who are far more worthy than Trump to lead their country towards a more just and truly democratic future. The return of good governance in the USA is possible, although at present this may seem impossibly difficult – but that is what bad leaders and bad governments want you to think.
49. Bad leaders and bad governance are two sides of the same coin. It should be clearer now than ever before, that all global institutions and all states need constitutions and laws that will prevent power ever finding its way into the hands of bad leaders. However, the whole world is unfortunately still a long way from that situation, which is one reason why many of the big global concerns have been so enduring.